Yesterday’s Country: Don’t Worry, They Can’t Innovate

The Chinese invented paper, compass, gunpowder and printing yet Americans convinced themselves they couldn't innovate

America is the past now. It didn’t need to be this way, but the US prefers to spend energies on transgender bathrooms than reigning in draining wars and military spending

For many years the United States has regarded itself as, and been, the world’s technological leader. One can easily make a long and impressive list of seminal discoveries and inventions coming from America, from the moon landings to the internet. It was an astonishing performance. The US maintains a lead, though usually a shrinking one, in many fields. But:

China has risen explosively, from being clearly a “Third World” country forty years ago to become a very serious and rapidly advancing competitor to America. Anyone who has seen today’s China (I recently spent two weeks there, traveling muchly) will have been astonished by the ubiquitous construction, the quality of planning, the roads and airports and high-speed rail, the sense of confidence and modernity.

Compare this with America’s rotting and dangerous cities, swarms of homeless people, deteriorating education, antique rail, deindustrialized midlands, loony government, and the military sucking blood from the economy like some vast leech, and America will seem yesterday’s country. The phrase “national suicide” comes to mind.

A common response to these observations from thunder-thump patriots is the assertion that the Chinese can’t invent anything, just copy and steal. What one actually sees is a combination of rapid and successful adoption of foreign technology (see Shanghai maglev below) and, increasingly, cutting edge science and technology. More attention might be in order. A few examples: A few examples from many that might be adduced:

“China Confirms Scientist Genetically Engineered Babies”

Supposedly the intent was to make the twins resistant to AIDS. It was done using CRISPR-Cas 9, a gene-editing technique invented in the West by Jennifer Dooudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier but quickly mastered by China. It seemed odd that AIDS resistance would be the goal since the disease is easily avoided. Maybe, I thought, for some technical reason the insertion was particularly easy. But then:

“China’s Genetically Edited Twins May Have Enhanced Brains ‘By Accident’”

“By accident” indeed. Since the researchers admitted being aware of the neurologic effects of CCR5, the gene in question, the experiment sure looked like a shot at increasing intelligence. But maybe not. Then:

“Chinese researchers insert human brain gene into monkeys, making them smarter”

Whether the insertion in fact had the effect described, I do not know, and the story maybe or may not be sensationalized. Of interest are, first, that it was an attempt to engineer intelligence, second, that it involved inserting a human gene in a (presumably) lower primate, and third, that the Chinese did it.

“China, Huawei to Launch 5G network in Shanghai Station”

Though 5G is usually presented as an improvement to smartphones, it is far more, and the Chinese seem poised to jump on it hard. See below.

“World’s First 5G powered Remote Brain Surgery Performed in China”

It is interesting that China and South Korea are clear leaders in 5G. The US, unable to compete seeks to prohibit its European vassals from dealing with HuaWei by threatening sanctions. Germany has refused to obey. .

Huawei’s 5G Dominance In The Post-American World – Forbes

Whether Forbes’ overstates the facts can perhaps be argued. That China has come from nowhere to be ahead in a crucial technology ought to be a wake-up call. That America has to rely on sanctions instead of better technology accentuates the point.

“More Than 510,000 Overseas Students Return to China”

This year. A couple of decades ago, Chinese students in the US often refused to return to a backward and repressive country. It now appears that Asia is where the action is and they want to be part of it.

“Chinese Bullet Trains Depend on Mega Bridges”

These things are everywhere. Click the link.Inmost countries roads and rails follow the contour of the land. China likes pillars.

Digging subways is expensive and disruptive, cutting highways through cities   of homes and business, so China goes with sky-trains. Building these takes about half the land as roadways. The bridges are built offsite and then erected with a special crane.

“China Develops Infrared Light to Alter Genes of Cancer Cells”

A team led by Professor Song Yujun from the Nanjing University’s College of Engineering and Applied Sciences designed an infrared light-responsive nano-carrier to be used for the CRISPR-Cas9 gene-editing tool, which will have great potential in cancer therapeutics. The strong penetrability of infrared light enables scientists to precisely control the gene editing tool in deep human tissue”

I am clueless as to the function of IR in this but, as with so very many stories coming out of China, it does not suggest copycatting. increasingly, the Chinese seem to following from in front.

“China Breaks Quantum Entanglement Record at Eighteen Qbits”

In a new record, Pan Jianwei and colleagues at the University of Science and Technology of China, eastern China’s Anhui Province, demonstrated a stable 18-qubit state. The previous record of 10 qubits was set by the same team. The breakthrough was made possible by simultaneously manipulating the freedom-paths, polarization, and orbital angular momentum of six photons.

“The speed of quantum computing grows exponentially as the number of qubits in an entangled state increases … the achievement of an 18-qubit entanglement this time has set the world record for largest entanglement state in all physical systems,” Wan

(Noah’s ark measured 300 Qbits, but the (barely) antediluvian technology has bee lost.)

Shkanghai Maglev Train

Open Date: Dec. 31st, 2002
Total Length: 30 kilometers (19 miles)
Highest Speed: 430km/h (267 mi/h)
Duration per Single Journey: 8 minutes
Frequency: 15-20 minutes
Route: Longyang Rd. – Pudong International Airport (PVG

Trains relying on magnetic levitation float on a field of magnetic repulsion, having no contact with rails. This reduces friction and ends wear on wheels and rails. China did not invent the technology but uses it well. Before this train, the trip from downtown to the airport took forty minutes to an hours. Now, eight minutes. The technology is German, the idea a century old, but the Chinese decided that they wanted it, and got it. The ability to make a decision and act on it without years of political wrangling and lawsuits gives China a major advantage over other countries.

The video is long, at 43 minutes, a bit ray-rah, and wanders briefly off into the history of elevated rail in Chicago but gives a good picture of the train, the technology at a non-specialist level, and the China in which it runs.

Rand: Chilling World War III Wargames show US Forces Crushed by Russia and China

“RAND Senior Defense Analyst David Ochmanek discussed the simulations at the Center for a New American Security (CNAS) in Washington D.C. last week. “In our games, where we fight China or Russia … blue gets its a** handed to it, not to put too fine a point on it,” he said, during a panel discussion. Blue denotes U.S. forces in the simulations.”

The reasons for this are several and belong in another column. The military’s utterly predictable response is “Send more money” instead of “Maybe we should mind our own business and spend on our economy.” The point here is that the world is changing in may ways and Washington seems not to have noticed.


The list could be extended at length, to cover numbers of patents awarded, scientific papers published, quantum communications, investment in education and technological research and development, supercomputers and chip design and many other things.

Beijing is clearly bent on Making China Great Again–as why should it not? Meanwhile America focuses more on transgender bathrooms and whether Bruce Jenner is a girl than on its endless and draining wars.

China sends its brightest to the world’s best technical school while America makes its universities into playpens for the mildly retarded. The country crumbles but spends drunkenly on defective fighter planes it doesn’t need in the first place.

This won’t work a whole lot longer.

Source: Fred on Everything

  1. David Bedford says

    America gets its ass handed to it in every scenario in a Rand study

  2. Godfree Roberts says

    The ‘China forty years ago’ meme is misleading.

    When Mao stepped down in 1974 China was producing jet aircraft, locomotives, oceangoing ships, ICBMs, hydrogen bombs and satellites and China had the best GINI in the world.

    He had reunited, reimagined, reformed and revitalized the largest, oldest civilization on earth, modernized it after a century of failed modernizations and ended thousands of years of famine.

    Despite the West’s crushing, twenty-five year embargo on food, finance, technology, medical and agricultural equipment and its exclusion of China from the family of nations Mao had banished the invaders, bandits and warlords, eliminated serious crime and drug addiction, doubled the population, its life expectancy and its literacy, liberated its women, educated its girls, erased its wealth disparity, given it infrastructure, grown the economy twice as fast as the West’s, kept the country debt-free, led four revolutions and succeeded in three.

  3. Leandro Augusto Pesce says

    It is priceless to watch the evil junk food empire crumbling faster than expected

  4. Ina Patzner says

    Chinese Student don’t pay for Chinese Universities, the Chinese Universities want smart&intelligent students& not money. US-Universities cost a sh*tload of $$ & after graduation many students have a sh*tload of debt. These debts are a heavy burden for employees & bad for career. USA needs a free higher education for smart students, but not more money or rich but not smart students. Science needs smart and intelligent people, but not only money!!

  5. CHUCKMAN says

    A few unneeded pejoratives, but nevertheless a good collection of stories on the amazing scientific progress China is making.

    It is just stunning that only forty years ago, China was ruled by a secular equivalent of the Middle Ages’ Catholic Church.

    In so short a time they have leapt, literally leapt, to a leadership role in a number of fields and a challenger in others.

    I regard this achievement of China’s sudden rise as one of two great miracles of our time, the other being personal computers and the Internet.

    They both are genuinely revolutionary.

    The native talent and ability at application one sees in Chinese people – and I have known several Chinese students studying abroad quite well – are what have been unleashed after being long suppressed.

    What a gigantic pool of talent and human capital.

    And China, while still nominally “communist,” has in fact morphed into something else, a country focused on meritocracy and led by some exceptionally intelligent people.

    It is offering a new model of development to the world.

    While the United States in fact takes retrograde steps in becoming more like something more like what China was – severe ideologues spending great time and effort on often meaningless achievements, such as trying to dominate everyone, instead of competing.

    My God, the 1950s and American notions turned on their heads.

    By the way, the business, often heard in the past about China not being able to innovate, comes from the same place as fairy tales like the American Dream and its even more childish Trumpian update, Make America great again.

    Americans, under the effects of a long easy dominance after WW II – a dominance as much the result of luck in having all competitors flattened as in their own efforts – really have come to believe, again as a form of secular religion, that they are special. God has blessed their enterprise. And America is indispensable. Always and everywhere such beliefs engender foolishness.

  6. BillA says

    were I young I would study Russian, then Chinese
    as the expression goes, the US will be a good place to be from

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.