Afghanistan Buries Another Empire

What would have been unthinkable 20 years ago is today a very real possibility: a Taliban victory

It’s easy to forget, but the United States by the end of 2001 thought it had won in Afghanistan. The CIA had undertaken an unofficial policy of war against Osama bin Laden back in 1998, and after 9/11, their agents were able to draw upon that planning to move quickly against Al Qaeda and the Taliban. The bombing began in October; Northern Alliance fighters were inside Kabul by mid-November. Osama bin Laden fled, possibly to Tora Bora and eventually to Pakistan. A new age was declared in Central Asia.

So rapid was the Taliban’s defeat that it threw some antiwar sorts off balance. The mood at the time was best summed up by Christopher Hitchens, who wrote a piece for The Guardian called “Ha ha ha to the pacifists.” Hitchens crowed, “It was obvious from the very start that the United States had no alternative but to do what it has done. It was also obvious that defeat was impossible. The Taliban will soon be history.”

Today, we might ask how much longer history is supposed to take. Make a running chronological leap over the invasion of Afghanistan, past Iraq, Libya, Syria, Yemen, above Arab Spring revolutions come and gone, landing and skidding into the present day, and you find the Taliban not only not defeated but in their strongest position in 20 years. The group now claims to control 70 percent of Afghanistan’s territory; a more cautious estimate by an Afghan news service puts it at 52 percent. Taliban fighters have seized highways and supply lines into Kabul. They’ve been inching towards the vital city of Kandahar.

All this during the Afghan winter, when frigid temperatures make fighting prohibitive; come springtime, observers expect the situation to only get worse. We are confronted now by what once would have seemed an unthinkable, even unpatriotic possibility: The Taliban could win in Afghanistan. After two decades of war, the United States could end up back where it started.

The prospect of a resurgent Taliban has prompted some to argue that America should stop withdrawing troops. Under the peace deal ratified at the end of Donald Trump’s presidency, the remaining 2,500 U.S. forces in Afghanistan are supposed to be out by May 1, though this was also contingent on the Taliban halting their offensive, which hasn’t happened. Still, it’s not like anything else we’ve tried has worked either, starting with Barack Obama’s troop surge in 2009. No amount of boots or dollars or willpower has achieved more than a lull in the violence. Yet we refuse to acknowledge as much. A congressional study group recently took a hard look at Afghanistan and came away with this groundbreaking conclusion: We should draw down only after security has improved. That, of course, is what we always say we’re going to do, only for that better security to remain elusive.

So why are we still in Afghanistan? Why can’t we finally succumb to reality and cut our losses? Three reasons come to mind.

The first is honor. No nation likes to lose a war, especially one with roots in the trauma of a terrorist attack. Because Afghanistan really was linked to 9/11—there’s no question Al Qaeda bombed the Twin Towers and was sheltered by the Taliban; Saddam Hussein, not so much—the conflict there has always maintained a certain Teflon in the American imagination. We think of it as the Good War amid the less palatable and more confusing Iraqs and Syrias. Even Barack Obama, elected during a year of war fatigue, maintained that the solution wasn’t to withdraw from the Middle East but to shift our focus from Iraq back to Afghanistan.

The second reason is what we might call elites on autopilot. Among those who prosecute and influence the war, a sense has set in that this is how things have been and therefore this is how things must be. America has always been at war with Afghanistan. The conflict has taken on the feel of a conveyor belt, with men and materiel sliding into one side of the machine and then out the other, supervised by elites who never bother to ask why the contraption exists in the first place. Read that congressional study report, read the various white papers that flit through the D.C. air like debris from an office fire, and you detect a kind of methodical conservatism at work. To withdraw troops would be disruptive, so best to keep Afghanistan the way it is, even if it isn’t working. And here are a few in-the-know terms to tide you over in the meantime: regional partnerskinetic action.

The third reason is the least common and also the most delusional: ideology. There remains a small clutch of thinkers who still cling to the old 2001 dream, who really do think that it is America’s vocation to spread liberal democracy around the world. To these armchair theorists, Afghanistan was never going to be wrapped up in two months or even 20 years; this is a hundred-years war, pitting the forces of liberalism, helmed by the indispensable nation America, against the forces of illiberalism. In the sweep of such a grand struggle, real difficulties against the Taliban become minor blips. Choose between Afghanistan and Iraq? We must fight in both, of course. This thinking was once best espoused by Norman Podhoretz, who wrote a book called World War IV: The Long Struggle Against Islamofascism. Today it finds voice in Robert Kagan, whose recent essay at Foreign Affairs chides Americans for trying to duck their never-ending responsibility to the world.

It’s all twaddle, of course, but this way of thinking nonetheless has a grain of a point: The situation in Afghanistan was always bigger than Afghanistan itself. It includes Pakistan (“AfPak,” as Richard Holbrooke used to call the two nations, until Pakistan pointed out that they were in fact different countries); the Taliban operates there, too, and its border with Afghanistan has served as a crossing point for countless terrorist fighters. It includes Saudi Arabia, whose decades of funding for Wahhabist schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan helped give rise to the extremism we see there today. It includes, though in a different way, Iran, which helped us wage war against the Taliban after 9/11. But that was an “axis of evil” speech ago; today such a collaboration would be unthinkable as Iran strengthens its ties to the Taliban.

The situation in Afghanistan also includes the Afghans themselves, whose country has been plagued by corruption we can’t manage, opium we can’t interdict, defiance we can’t quell. And it includes American leaders, who knew the war had stalled and covered it up, as the Washington Post revealed in the so-called Afghanistan Papers. The picture that comes into focus is not of a missed opportunity or a needed correction, but a mission made impossible by forces too large for us to control. Ex post facto declarations like, “we could have done more to fight Afghan corruption,” run smack into a simple question, “how?” Initial victory against the Taliban was always possible, even easy; engineering an Afghanistan able to resist that same Taliban in the long term was not.

Afghanistan has been called the “graveyard of empires.” And while America’s frustration there might not prove as dramatic as, say, the Soviet retreat in 1988, it’s worth taking stock of how much we’ve lost since the war began. Twenty years ago, we were optimistic about peace in the Middle East; today we’re cynical. Twenty years ago, we were respected throughout much of the world; today we wonder whether that same world has gone post-American. Twenty years ago, we had a fiscal surplus; today we run massive deficits and a national debt larger than our entire economy, thanks in part to our wars. Twenty years ago, our democracy seemed like a model for places like Afghanistan; today it’s as anxious and uncertain as it’s been in my lifetime.

That isn’t to say the Afghan war alone drove our decline. But it does stand as a relic of a past age, a manifestation of a folly that left us weaker than we were before. After all this time, after all this blood, there is only one thing left to do: Bring the troops home.

Source: The American Conservative

  1. Ilya G Poimandres says

    Just that bit about the Taliban defo doing 9/11.. two planes, three buildings.

    But the author spits in the right direction at least, even if blindfolded!

  2. William A White says

    It’s the Heroine! It’s always the money fellas.

    1. Barbara Bogo says

      Very much so!

      1. Jose says

        Makes you wonder if the fentanyl ‘epidemic’ is an effort by traditional drug makers to compete with the competition. I imagine even USA would hesitate to fent its own citizens.

  3. Barbara Bogo says

    Waht about Opium?

  4. yuri says

    desperate incompetent amerikans suiciding

    1. XSFRGR says

      The West will be remembered as the only civilization that chose to commit suicide, and like most people who are suicidal they can’t be stopped. Hopefully Russia, and China will not be harmed by Western death spasms.

      1. Jose says

        seppuku ?

        1. XSFRGR says

          Unfortunately, no; the West is nowhere near that honorable.

  5. XSFRGR says

    Can my fellow Americans ever stop lying (Because Afghanistan really was linked to 9/11—there’s no question Al Qaeda bombed the Twin Towers and was sheltered by the Taliban;)? Since this statement came under the subject of “honor” it begs the question, “Do my fellow Americans even know the definition of honor?”

  6. Jerry Hood says

    I had solved 911 which was done for Novus Ordo Seclorum in 2033: the real Mayan prophecues investigated-monument 6 Tortuguero( The Watchers), scroll to the COMMENTS, and read first 4 of them!

  7. Jerry Hood says

    911 was domestic terrorist ” false flag” operation by the zionist Deep State for Jew World Order in 2033!!!

    1. Eddy says

      Absoluetly spot on.

    2. Kris says

      Indeed, Osama, the Taliban or Afghanistan had ZERO to do with 9-11. Israel on the other hand….

  8. grant hamilton says

    website should be anti- cluedo,

  9. Eddy says

    Quote, there’s no question Al Qaeda bombed the Twin Towers and was sheltered by the Taliban”; Unquote.
    Really ????? Where is the evidence to sustain that claim ???? That one sentence destroys the whole article. Propaganda at it’s worst.

    1. Kris says

      ALL evidence leads to the MOSSAD and CIA, without any question whatsoever!

  10. RoHa says

    It includes Saudi Arabia, whose decades of funding for Wahhabist schools in Pakistan and Afghanistan helped give rise to the extremism we see there today.”

    And the US funding and support for the Afghan resistance to the USSR.

  11. John says

    “… there’s no question Al Qaeda bombed the Twin Towers” … really? That’s a remarkably ill-informed proposition. A pity, since the rest of the analysis seems well-founded.

  12. Jerry Hood says

    Lower Manhattan is the local, zionist copy of the Eden in Milky Way( her Dark Cleft as Female Grotto), where biblical Eve got her ” hairy APPLE” to Adam to conceive…This is the true reason, why the local populace nicked New York City as ” Big APPLE”! ( There is a DOZEN such copies,worldwide)!
    The zionist Deep State from the Blue Lodge of the West, not only printed the US Skyscrapers calendar counting the END of current Precessional year in 2032, in Nat.Geographic magazine,February 1989 issue, pages 156-157, but it is closely tied by DATES and NUMBER PATTERNS to the oficially released MSM 911 Database!
    With the masonic 1$ bill symbols and modern US galactic flag, there is 11x times the same DATE of 2032= END of current Great Year, and 2033 as the year of Novus Ordo Seclorum!
    911 was the ” masonic elite” First horse of apocalypse with lots of lost lives and human rights! Covid 19 is global and more deadly 2nd horse, with more human rights lost, globally, thanks to these satanic globalists! In 2022 the world will face huge economic crisis, and in 2023, the 3rd horse arrives as STARVATION, blamed on Covid crisis and bad harvests due to bad weather caused by ” global warming”( the Black swan disasters)…By then, msny will starve to death, and all human rights shall be shackled by the 9th Circle of satan= globalists! And from here, no problem to guide the madd and hungry nations to the Depopulation= Armageddon = WW3 , where Russia is designed as tge Christian St.George- the Dragon Slayer, see their Two headed eagle at its center! Russia will slay the ” great USAtan” just in an hour by its hypersonic missiles and Poseidon submarines nuclear kamikadze drones!
    But there shall be no people to ” celebrate victory”- only billions of dead, with only ” ideal” 500 million true ” holocaust survivors”, traumatized for generations to come in the rising new civilisation, as points out the Rosucrucian apocalyptic and postapocalyptic Georgia Guidestones!

    1. Jerry Hood says

      The X shaped Georgia Guidestones masonic monument was opened on March 22, 1980. March 22= masonic 322 number of Vernal Equinox starting point of Precessional year, and 3+2+2= number 7. 1980= number 9, and number 8 is in the 8 languages on the 8 sides of the panels…
      The zionist terrorists knocked down the Twin Towers as number 8( now are there 2 squared holes= Memorial) + WTC 7= 15, natching the 15 disciples named in the Bible, and the 7+8 skyscrapers in the US Skyscrapers calendar, or the 15 erected moai statues on Abu Tongariki,Eastern island, plus the 15 pyramids around the Way of Dead in Teotihuacan, where the main 3 pyramids, have together 15 steps: Moon=4+Sun=5+ Kukulkan=6 stepped pyramid. In cluding the 9 pyramids of Giza, tied to the 6 stepped pyramid of YoSeR/ DJoSeR( as 15).. .
      The same conmen like Silverstein, rebuilt the original 7WTC complex as: 1WTC+3+4+7WTC=15!
      As 4 buildings, and on the 5th one(2WTC), these conmen ket erect onky foundation, ” fir lack of tenants”= jew lie in Wikipedia!
      Since we are in their satanic 2nd horse of apocalypse, they couldn’t erect in this age building number 5= 2WTC for this reason: 1WTC+3+4+7= 15 + 2WTC = makes the 17th day of 2nd months when the biblical Great Flood started in the 5 Books of Moses= Pentateuch, where we aren’t yet!
      First must be finished the 4 horses, and only then arrives Novus Ordo Seclorum in 2033, and after that 5 Books of Moses with Great Flood on scorched Earth by 4th horseman,
      starting new cycle of life on Earth,and new civilisation! That’s the ancient Ennead of 9, consisting from 4+5! Remember Flight AA77 turning 270 degrees westwardly into Pentagon between the 4th and 5th stairways leading to heliport? There is 77 generations from God to Chfist in Luke, chapter 3, and 270 is the gematria name value of Y.S.R., as YoSeR, and INRI, to masons as Ignated Nature Renews Itself – after the watery baptism by Flood!
      In their masonic ” secret doctrine”, the soul in life after life, enters the River of Life= Milky Way trough X shaped ancient Orion as Sand Clock/ Kal Purush with originally having 7 stars, and flows goward the galactic Doubke center= Womb to Judgement and cleansing= purification of memorues, Womb, where souls are rejuvenated and resurrected, marked by number 8 from ancient Egypt to China, but in Serpent cultures of Mesoamerica as 9+11 starred Jar/ Pot/ Bowl/ Cup, etc., of the Potter- Creator= YoSeR= Aquarian Age, starting new Great Year,new life cycle on Earth,new civilisation, and new octave….
      From there, the soul flows at apointed ” time” in acvordance with the karmic and galactic laws to the Birth canal- stargate in 9 starred Swan constellation, which is aldo known as the Northern Cross and stretched Bow from Persia to China….

      911 was done for Novus Ordo Seclorum in 2033, and as above, so below, in our Dual and Bipolar world! !!!

  13. Reece Khan says

    Stupid idea was invading Afghanistan, if you know the people, you would know they love a good war, they find some sort of honour in it,

  14. Bonard says

    Os EUA estão derretendo…kkkkkkk

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.